A space to discuss FME Form
Recently active
Can anyone give me some advice on getting GIS-styling symbols and polygon fills using the AutoCAD DWG writer?I’m not an AutoCAD expert but have this week been getting to grips with concepts such as blocks. With help from a colleague, we’ve managed to create a template with blocks for a range of point symbols and got my Form script to output points to a layer referencing the appropriate block name so that an appropriate symbol appears. Note: I have too many symbol types to put each on a separate layer. Is this the use of blocks to implement cartographic symbols a sound approach?The next thing I’d like to do is have some symbol fills for polygon features. e.g. trees representing woodland. What approach would be best to implement what would be a simple custom pattern fill in GIS software? I’m already aware than Form outputs simple polygons as normal, but complex ones (e.g. with holes) via sequentially named blocks. What about using custom hatches?Finally, I’d like my AutoCAD drawing to ha
Hi everyone,I'm working on an FME automation to update existing telecom conduit geometries using surveyed locator points.Current workflow: Surveyed locator points are provided in a CSV file containing latitude, longitude, and Record Index. I use VertexCreator and LineBuilder to create a surveyed line based on the Record Index. Existing conduit geometries are retrieved from an API. I'm using SpatialFilter and AnchoredSnapper to identify nearby conduits and adjust their geometry to follow the surveyed line. The challenge:The surveyed points may follow a single conduit or multiple connected conduits. The CSV does not contain conduit IDs, so the automation needs to determine which existing conduit geometries should be updated.There may also be connecting conduits near the surveyed route. When the main conduit geometry is adjusted, the endpoints of connecting conduits need to move accordingly to maintain network connectivity.For example, in one test case, two connected conduits need t
How to set the Elevation Attribute for an IFCBUILDINGSTOREY class correctly?I have a workbench dedicated to write the ifc-file of a building I have created project, site, building, buildingstorey and spaces and related correctly via globalID and parentID. The file will be written and can be opened in most IFC-Viewer applications. BUT: even though I have created an attribute named “ifc_elevation” and set this to be written with the buildingstorey features, it is not written into the STEP-Code (10th attribute of the buildingstorey class). I downloaded the file from the BIMfit-challenge - this does not write the elevation either.is there a solution, or is FME not capable of writing the elevation -attribute? The screenshot shows the attributes I am sending to the writer.FME 2026.2 / IFC API writer / IFC 4.3 Thanks a lot in advance for any help!
Hello all, i’m using FME workbench 2025.1 and JSON Flattener.the schema looks like:"$schema": "https://json-schema.org/draft-07/schema", "title": "Generated Schema", "description": "Generated from JSON data", "type": "object", "properties": { "Events": { "type": "array", "items": { "type": "object", "properties": { "Id": { "type": "string" }, "Deleted": { "type": "boolean" }, "EventId": { "type": "integer" }, "InformationText": { "type": "string" }, "CategoryId": { "type": "integer", "enum": [ 12, 13, 9 ] }, "CategoryDescriptor": { "type": "string", "enum": [ "Fault", "High", "Status" ] }, "State": { "type": "string", "enum": [
similar to this question: but a little different, in that i need a dynamic range.i’m going to be using this form in an automated flow that triggers once per min. i want to see filter everything that falls within the last minute.my input to the tester looks like:UTC_Current_Time SrcName CreationTime EventId SrcState 15:17 HLD_HW_W_West_Ret 15:17 6211 Active 15:17 FTB_HVAC13_RaCo2 15:17 6205 Active 15:17 CCR_RmE20B_DPtoE20A_Lo 15:15 1029 Active 15:17 CCR_RmE20B_DPtoE20A 15:12 1028 Active 15:17 SHW01D900 15:12 6176 Active 15:17 NSB_CHW_CHLR1_Ret 15:09 11232 Active 15:17 FTB_HVAC13_RaCo2 15:16 6206 Active what i want to do is have a tester for within a min of the current UTC time column.so both FTB_HVAC13_RaCo2 would qualify, but CCR_RmE20B_DPtoE20A_Lo would not - because it’s 2 mins behind, not just one. i thought it might be as simple as this: but that doesn’t seem to work: next i tried to leverage the @DateTimeDiff
I'm trying to use the AreaGapAndOverlapCleaner to fill gaps in my polygons. This works fine without grouping, but as soon grouping is enabled, the donuts and other slivers in the polygons are not filled any more. See screenshots below. The tolerance in both situations is 25cm. The only changed setting is the grouping. I used the AreaGapAndOverlapCleaner for many years now and never experienced this before. In most situations I used ‘automatic’ as tolerance.I'm using Form 2026.2. I also tried to recreate the process in 2025.2.4 and still experience the same issue. Does anyone know why the donuts and slivers are not removed when grouping is enabled? Grouping disabled: all small holes are filled (as expected) Grouping enabled: small holes and slivers still present.
Hi everyone,I'm having a performance issue with an FME workspace that I previously used for tree canopy analysis.The workspace processes classified LiDAR point clouds along with DEM and DSM rasters. It uses transformers including PointCloudFilter, PointCloudToPointCoercer, HullAccumulator (Alpha 0.5), and RasterMosaicker.The workflow previously took around 8–12 minutes per tile. However, since upgrading to FME 2026.3.1.1, it takes significantly longer and doesn't complete.What I've observed: FME memory usage increases to around 50 GB, with overall system memory reaching 98%. CPU usage remains relatively low. The log shows that LiDAR filtering completes, but processing continues for a long time without further progress messages. Eventually, I get this warning: Failed to free sufficient memory to reach the process usage limit.I've also tested running the child workspace independently, rather than through WorkspaceRunner, but the problem persists.Has anyone experienced similar perf
How would I go about reading these polygons (which are buffered lines) from Smallworld into FME without FME filling in the gaps in the polygon. Alternatively, How would I restore the donut geometry of the polygons? I have tried GeometryCoercer, DonutBuilder, etc. with no luck. This will be written to a KML.
I am having some issues converting a .NVD to .GDB to display in ArcGIS Pro. I can get the attributes all across but cannot view the geometry in FME Does anyone have any guidance on how to transform the geometry so it displays in a geodatabase in ArcGIS Pro?Thanks
Hi all,I’m trying to create points at 1 m intervals along a line, with a sequential ID starting at 2000.As shown in the screenshot below, I need the sequence to start at the south-western end of the line with ID 2000, then increase by 1 for every metre as it follows the line towards the north-east and then back towards the north-west.So essentially:Start of line = ID 2000 Next point, 1 m along the line = 2001 Next point = 2002 Continue incrementing by 1 following the actual direction/path of the lineI have tried using the DistanceChopper from the FME Hub to split the line into 1 m segments. I then calculate the X/Y coordinates of the start/end points, use a VertexCreator, and finally a Sorter based on the X coordinate.This works up to the location marked X in my screenshot. However, because the line curves back on itself in the X direction, sorting by X no longer represents the correct order along the line. What I really need is a way of ordering the generated points by their distance/
I have a workspace using a ChangeDetector to maintain data in a SharePoint Online list, using a Microsoft SharePoint Server List writer (we are blocked from using the Graph API, so the Microsoft SharePoint Online List reader/writer are not options for us).When a value has been written to a field in the list but is later removed in the source/revised data, the ChangeDetector recognizes this and sends either a null or blank/empty value to the writer, without error. But, the null/empty/blank value is not actually written or accepted, and the stale value persists.I’ve found that if I use a NullAttributeMapper and map Empty, Missing, and Null values to a New Value and set that to a single space character, that SharePoint actually writes the null/blank value over the existing value. For anyone trying to do the same, this might be an important point.The issue that I’ve run into is that Date/DateTime-type fields will not accept a space as input. I’ve tried writing in 00000000 and it is also re
Hi everyone,I'm working with FME Form 2025.1 to update features in an ArcGIS Enterprise feature service that uses branch versioning.I'm using a Feature Service Writer to update existing features based on their GlobalID. The workflow runs successfully, and I'm able to update certain fields without any issues.However, I've noticed that a few specific fields aren’t retaining the value I'm sending through FME, while other fields are updated successfully using the exact same workflow.I suspect this is happening because of the attribute rules we have currently set up. The fields I’m unable to update from FME are the same ones that have a corresponding attribute rule.To make it even weirder, you’d think that with any update (even if from FME), the attribute rules would go into place and start triggering the rules to fill in the other fields we have rules for, but only the fields I’m updating via FME are changed.The challenge: The feature service is used in a production environment with branch
Dear Feature Manipulation Experts,The GeometryPropertyExtractor is a transformer I never used before. So of course, my first experiment with it failed.I wanted to know what type of geometry the GeometryValidator spits out after having repaired them. I put in areas (polygons) and expected all output, whether repaired or not, to be areas as well. Sometimes, however this was not the case. I used the GeometryFilter to separate the areas from other geometries.In an attempt to find out what the others are, I discovered the GeometryPropertyExtractor. To see how it works, I attached it to the area-output of the GeometryFilter, expecting to find a geometryproperty (area or polygon) attached to all features. Instead, all input is rejected!As you can see in the Feature Information pane, the rejected features do have a geometry (polygon) and a type (area):As I am writing this I wonder why I did not think of simply using these FME attributes. I blame friday afternoon for that.But still I wonder: w
Hello everyone,I'm facing an issue when reading multiple tables from ArcSDE and writing them to a File Geodatabase using a dynamic schema.I'm using fme_feature_type as the destination feature class name. However, translation fails for some tables.After investigating the issue, I found that some tables contain Esri-specific attributes such as shape.len and shape.area, and other esri objects which seem to cause problems when writing to the File Geodatabase.My idea is to automatically remove any Esri-specific attributes that might cause compatibility issues and then write all tables successfully to the File Geodatabase.My first approach:I'm working with FME Form 2024 and trying to clean up the schema before writing data to a File Geodatabase.My workflow is: Use FeatureReader to read the source data and retrieve its schema through the Schema output port. Use ListExploder to split the attribute{} list into individual schema attribute definitions. Use Tester to filter out unwanted Esri-
I have discovered a bug (and a workaround) concerning TempPathnameCreator version 1 in FME Form 2024.2.5.2.First of all, because of the Security Hardening in FME 2026.2+ and Backport Versions (in this case FME Form 2024.2.5.2) the TempPathnameCreator must be updated to version 1 in all workspaces that use this transformer (for more information see https://support.safe.com/hc/en-us/articles/49062482561421-TempPathnameCreator-in-FME-2026-2-and-backports).The bug I discovered is that in FME Form 2024.2.5.2 the attribute after 'Pathname’ is not exposed. This breaks all workspaces in FME Form 2024.2.5.2 that use the TempPathnameCreator, even after updating the transformer to version 1. The workaround is simple: add an AttributeExposer to manually expose this attribute.Edit: I notice that after manually exposing the attribute it often ends up as an extra attribute in my output. So the attibute has to be removed explicitly as well.Note: I also tested this in version 2026.3.1.1; in that versio
so, i’m trying to use Json Extractor on a response body that looks like this: { "Events": [ { "Id": "MSU_S1:GmsDevice_1_860100_12582917.Alarm.OffNormal:_alert_hdl.2._value~639301453601600000~3216~8311", "Deleted": false, "EventId": 8311, "InformationText": "", "CategoryId": 9, "CategoryDescriptor": "High", "State": "Unprocessed", "Cause": "Off Normal (OK)", "SrcPropertyId": "MSU_S1:GmsDevice_1_860100_12582917.Alarm.OffNormal:_alert_hdl.2._value", "SrcObservedPropertyId": "MSU_S1:GmsDevice_1_860100_12582917.Alarm.OffNormal:_alert_hdl.2._value", "SrcState": "Quiet", "Timer": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", "SrcSystemId": 2, "SrcViewName": "ManagementView", "SrcViewDescriptor": "Management View", "SrcDesignation": "ManagementView.FieldNetworks.PSS_BT.Hardware.HVACPSS01.Local_IO.PSS001100", "SrcLocation": "Project.Field Networks.PSS BT.Hardware.RM A51 PXM01(OLD MBC32).Local_IO.STATUS", "SrcName": "PSS0011
i’m new to APIs so i am pretty sure i am just missing something here, but i am struggling with authenticating with an API endpoint that works fine with postman.the API documentation shows an example POST:using the above, i was able to put a request together in Postman for testing purposes (same machine as is running Form)Here is my request in postman and response POST https://{my domain}:443/{my site}/api/token?grant_type=password&username=XXXXXXXXX&password=XXXXXXXXXXGrant_type: grant_type=passwordPostman-Token: 19fb51a2-3948-4436-a2e0-062dc6b33649Content-Type: application/x-www-form-urlencodedContent-Length: 62Host: {my domain}:443User-Agent: PostmanRuntime/2.16.1Accept: */*Accept-Encoding: gzip, deflate, brConnection: keep-aliveRequest Bodygrant_type: "password"username: "XXXXXXXXX"password: "XXXXXXXXXX"Response HeadersCache-Control: no-cachePragma: no-cacheContent-Length: 966Content-Type: application/json;charset=UTF-8Content-Language: en-USExpires: -1Server: X-Powered-By:
I have 3D points (XYZ), with some attributes. The points have fixed distances; Z: 0.5m, X: 50m, Y: 20m. There's a "stack" of 200 points at each location. I want to convert these points into voxels, with a dimension of 0.5m*50m*20m (ZXY) per voxel. The output format must be netCDF.However, I can't get it to work. I managed to write a file ArcGIS Pro recognizes as voxel layer, but nothing is visible. Another attempt is recognized as multidimensional data (in 2D) only. In both cases I used NumericRasterizer, and the netCDF writer seems to accept only raster data. Can it write voxel data, and if, how? Below are some screenshots for clarification. Points in 2D - the blue line is 20m; red is 50m (perpendicular to the rows); the pale yellow area is what I’m using for my tests (the dataset has about 1.8m points in total) Points in 3D Mockup with point symbology - desired result 2D netCDF
I am trying to extract some GIS data from an IFC file containing manholes, pipes and ducts. The IFC file have some small gaps at bends, like this: I’m extracting the top facing faces in the IFC and simplify to one polygon per IFC element. I still get these small gaps in my GIS data:I have tested the Generalizer with a lot of different algorithms and settings, but those that seem to be able to remove these (like the Wang algorithm) removes my Z values… Is there a way to simplify or smoothen the data to remove these while retaining the 3D area boundaries?
Hi, I am new to read the CAD files in FME. May I please get an example of a CAD file and how to read in FME - basic steps to follow
Hi, I am migrating an FME Flow Azure AD web service from FME Form 2025.0.1 to 2026.3.0.0 (Build 26589). The upgrade to FME 2026 introduced the redirect strategy, due to removal of embedded browser, which was working previously, so I know the details I’ve used should work. Error:I’m using no secret. I’ve tested using both Loopback Interface Redirect and Proxy Redirect, same result on both. Everything has been set up following instructions outlined in: https://support.safe.com/hc/en-us/articles/39450156608781-External-Browser-Authentication-in-FME-Form I’ve set up everything as instructed in azure too. I’m stumped by this issue. Not sure how to even begin to debug it. FME form has no logs for me to assess. Azure has only basic logs which offer no answers.|Can anyone give me some ideas on what I can try and check to resolve this? Is using tinker the only way forward? Happy to share the full web service config if useful.Thanks
Hi all.I was wondering whether it’s possible to get FME to read files inside a ZIP, that doesn’t use the ZIP extension, but is a zip file ?Many software packages utilize ZIP, including FME itself, to store groups of files.I’m trying to read QGIS project files, and the QGZ extension is a zip file containing QGS files. But FME rejects all QGZ notation when used in place of zip.C:/my/path/my.zip/**/*.qgs works fine, butC:/my/path/my.qgz/**/*.qgs does not.Is there a tweak to accomplish that ?Cheers
Hi everyone,We have encountered an issue when reading protected Excel (.xlsx) files using FME Form 2026.3.1.1 and would like to check whether anyone else has experienced similar behaviour.Test scenario:We have an XLSX file containing data across a large number of columns, from A to LZ. When opening the file in Microsoft Excel, the file is protected and displays the "Enable Editing" button.We tested the same file using two different FME versions: FME Desktop 2022.1.2: Reads the entire file correctly, including all columns from A to LZ, without requiring the user to click "Enable Editing" in Excel. FME Form 2026.3.1.1: When the "Enable Editing" button has not been pressed, the Excel Reader only reads columns A to Z. The remaining columns (AA to LZ) are not detected/read. FME Form 2026.3.1.1: If we manually open the file in Excel and click "Enable Editing" before running the workspace, all columns are read correctly. Expected behaviour:We would expect FME Form 2026.3.1.1 to read the e
Good day,I have a line with a center point on it. I would like to create a polygon around this line that should intersect the last and first vertex of the line. The longer side should be 2m long (as long as the line) and parallel to the line. The shorter side should be perpendicular to the line, 1.6m long and intersecting the line halfway. How can I achieve this ?
Long time user of FME but new to 2026. Just re-opened a workbench and ran it. Whilst running, all cache indicators are green, but on completion, these ones turn yellow: Clearing the data cache/temp files does not fix this. These are my caching settings: It goes green if I tell it to use incomplete caches. Which I don’t really want to do. So it seems to think that those caches are incomplete, when they should not be. The only warnings are that ‘data caching is on.’ Help…? What stupid thing am I doing? Incidentally, it worked fine yesterday.