Architecture

After I finished the installation to 2024.2 (upgrading from 2023.1) I seemed to have the same issue as described in this post: So I followed all the suggestions in the Best answer by laurawatsafe.(I blured out url's and server names in my screenshots for privacy reasons)As described by laurawatsafe I ended up with both localhost and Serverhostname. In the screenshot below you can clearly see that at the moment after I stopped the Engines and was able to remove localhost, there were 0 standard engines assigned to localhost.So at this point I thought my problem was fixed. (I am wondering why this issue is in 2024.2 as it was fixed in 2018/2019. So this bug seems to have reappeared.)But now I have some very strange behavior in the interface:I tried to assign the two engines to my server, but after the delete action of localhost is shows 2/2 engines in use: This gives error: I end up with this:  When I sort on hostname on the Engines tab, there still seems to be a refference to localhost: 

I just had a little adventure in restoring the FME Server (we are on 2022) configuration database - that is the internal postgres database for configuration and job history. We will move it to mssql eventually...I managed to hose our test server the other day - it is this problem I wrote a post about here:Now we have had a scheduled job that creates a full pg_dump backup of the data, and the latest run was just 2 days old! We have had the backup system in place, but we have never had to do a restore - the backup is also for archiving the history.It took a lot of trial and error and experimentation to figure out how do it, but eventually I got there.* Drop the fmeserver database* Recreate the database* Restore from backup (schema + data)* Grant permissionsHere are my more detailed notes...https://lnkd.in/dz-usUSU

Hello, I am using FME Flow 2021 with 2 VMs and a Load Balancer all on Windows 2016. In Windows File Explorer (not in FME Flow), what folder/subfolder(s) are the uploaded workspaces and automations stored in? Is there a link to a document that explains what files are stored in what File Explorer folders or something similar for FME Flow? Thank you in advance for your assistance. 

Hello FME Folks, I know that we can run multiple FME Desktop version on same Windows Machine with same licence.Can we do that with FME Server on different Windows Server machines?We have a SmallWorld DB incompatibility for our FME Server upgrade and EO SmallWorld upgrade will happen later.SO, we have to run two FME Server environment. Is that a red flag ? OK?Thanks,Vivek

Hello everyoneIn a project I'm working on, we use the 2021 version and the results of the processes are stored on a disk so that the user can download those results to their personal computer using the URL; for example:https://<url>/download/results/110096.zipAs we understand it, download is like an alias of the path on the disk and Results is a directory on the disk, for example the results are in G:\FME\Results and 110096 is a compressed file with the resultsThese results must remain on that disk for 3 days so that the user has the opportunity to download them, but the problem is that due to the size of the results files, the disk fills up and the processes failWe have another disk with more space. How could we change it so that the results are saved on that other disk and users have access to download them?The person who did the configuration no longer works for our company but told me that to change disks it was only necessary to "expose" the directories of that disk in the T

Does FME Flow (server) have a way to store FME workbench metadata? I can’t seem to find anything.I mean metadata about the fme workbench, for example info such as describing what it does, who its made for (customer), having some tags and a owner doesn’t cut it. Also a way to export this information would be useful. How does everyone else manage their FME Flow servers with hundreds of workbenches and automations?Open to any third party application suggestions too.Thanks.

Installing FME flow for the first time.  Looking at it from IT perspective, not an FME user myself.  Current users are using FME Form on Windows, and I’m upgrading this FME Flow server.  We have very low load, but growing and so I’m moving our “operations” from under a user’s desk to our data center.   We mange a lot of Windows and Linux systems, but prefer Linux when there’s a choice, and Linux is genuinely fully supported by vendor.  Initially I thought it had to run on Windows do to ArcGIS jobs which apparently requires Windows ESRI DLLs.  But upon closer read of docs, it appears that a distributed install allows all components on Linux except engine(s) for ArcGIS jobs.  While I lean toward Linux, I also favor simplicity and eschew unnecessary complexity, and obviously a distributed install is more complex, but depending on the specific software, more complex doesn’t necessarily mean that much more work.  I don’t however need fault-tolerantAny recommendations?  Windows single-system

We are planning our 2024 upgrade and need to know when the anticipated release date is for FME 2024.2. We are looking to upgrade soon, but may delay some depending on the anticipated release date. Thank you in advance for your help!

Where to get the FME for Home Use, like ArcGIS Home Use license?

Hi All,We are working on adding new FME Engines on a Separate Linux Machine in a fault-tolerance environment where two FME Cores have been configured. Following the FME Flow Administrator’s Guidehttps://docs.safe.com/fme/html/FME-Flow/AdminGuide/Adding_FME_Engines_on_Separate_Machine.htmThe install instructions have this step on the Linux section,The installer prompts you for the name of the <coreHost>. In a fault-tolerant installation, the primary <coreHost> should always be specified. Do not specify the failover host.Here we are not very clear. We have two FME Flow Cores.first, how do we know which one is supposed to be the primary or the failover host between two Cores?Secondly, if say that the first Core to start can be considered the primary, what happens to the engines on a Separate Engine if the primary Core is down?Can anyone give us some helps on this?Thanks,-John

I have an express install of FME Flow (2024.1) on a Azure VM and I am having troubles getting a stable connection to imap.gmail.com. The validation is sporadic. It will validate and be working and recieving notifications and then it will give me an error that the port or security are not correct. Thu-11-Jul-2024 06:04:41.318 AM : com.sun.mail.util.MailConnectException: Couldn't connect to host, port: imap.gmail.com, 993; timeout 15000;I have enabled inbound and outbound rules over port 993 for imap.gmail.com on Azure. I am not sure what else I could be missing. Any help is appreciated. 

I get this error installing FME Flow 2024.1 on Windows 10. I don’t believe it’s related to the only other forum thread on this error as I have 30 GB of free space on C:.    

Dear FME friends, We upgraded our fme 2023.1.1 to 2024.0.3. To test the new version, several test were done on the new environment, among which a performancetest for databases PostgreSQL and Oracle.The workspaces that are run in a automation do 3 things:Download open data en put this data in our own postgresql datase Read the data from the database Delete the data from the databaseWe saw strange things going on in the numbers for both our postgresql and Oracle test. We saw for the postgresql test that the CPU-time was longer than the elapsed time. Furthermore the running time in 2024 was generally longer than in 2021.  Please find attached the examples of the runs on fme 2021 and fme 2024. It is clearly seen something is wrong. Can you explain why in the 21 runs the elapsed time seems to be more than the cpu time and in the 24 run it is the other way around. The used dataset is exacly the same in both workspaces publised on fme server/flow.We did the same experiment 5 times for several

Is it possible to test (from within FME) which operating system an FME workspace is running on?

HelloWondering if anyone else has run into these issues when installing FME Flow 2024.1?  We’re testing an in-place upgrade process on a development system using the express installation.Engine name isn’t being updated correctly.  We changed the configuration per this post, and appears to resolve the issue . Also noticing a problem in the “Start FME Server” / "Restart FME Server” workflows.  Command line is reporting an error that seems related to the FME Database.  

I got an error from FME 2019.2 and FME 2022.1. The error is " Python Exception <OSError>: Could not find a suitable TLS CA certificate bundle, invalid path: C:\\Program Files\\PostgreSQL\\15\\ssl\\certs\\ca-bundle.crt".Anyone has idea how to fix?

We have a domain account setup to run the  3 services required for FME Server 2022 to function.  My question is simple, does this account need to be apart of the Administrators group? 

HiI am currently looking to create a CityGML model of the buildings in a specific area using various spatial data. I have followed this tutorial Point Cloud to 3D Terrain Model with Buildings and obtained an Adobe 3D PDF model of the buildingsBut I now want to convert this model into a CityGML LOD2 model. Is this possible?Since I have just started using FME and am not very familiar with the software, what should my next steps be? Could you provide some useful references? Thanks for your advice😊

Hi allI have FME Flow installed in production environment with 2 nodes (Fault-Tolerant installation).I have now 4 workspaces that i have scheduled every 4 minutes.My DB Administrator see many query like this UPDATE fme_node_health SET modifieddate = :1 , expirydate = :2 , timeout = :3 , expiry = :4  WHERE process = :5  AND name = :6UPDATE fme_lock SET val = :1 , uuid = :2 , expiry = :3  WHERE lock_key = :4  AND (uuid = :5  OR expiry < :6 )They occours more time and and fill the disk space dedicated to Oracle logs.It's the first time it's happened to me and I don't understand if it depends on the scheduling or the Fault-Tolerant type installation.Can someone help me?Thanks a lot

Hi,Is there a way to configure FME Server/Flow, so that logs are  automatically saved not only to standard .log file, but also to .json file (containing JSON formatted data)? It would be very helpful when it comes to further log information processing.

I’m trying to debug an issue with the Job Submitter Service (I haven't actually tried any of the other services) .I have a process which runs fine from the FME Server UI (FME Server 2021). I can fill in the parameters (also upload an input file) etc. The jobs runs.If instead I try and run this using the jobsubmitter service via REST call - e.g., http://Host/fmejobsubmitter/Repository/workspace.fmw?parametersThe response is a 404. What is interesting to me is that I’m able to use the URL without the parameters and get back a proper response - that is for example: http://Host/fmejobsubmitter/Repository/workspace.fmw. It seeeeems like the issue is somehow related to the input file, however, in that case I would expect the job to fail rather than return a 404. so to me it seems like there is a problem actually submitting the jobI’ve checked permissions and the user definitely has access to the repository where the workspace is, and in my testing removing the permissions returns a 401 ERROR

Hi All,I am new to FME Flow. We are installing FME Flow 2023.1. We are setting up a two-tier distributed FME Flow environment with a machine which hosts FME Flow Core and Web server, and two separate distributed machines where the workspaces will be executed within the same network.  Let’s say I have an automated scheduled job which supposed to run at one of distributed machine at a certain time. For some reasons, the FME Flow Core machine is down at the time when the scheduled job supposed to run. When the FME Flow Core machine down, is the scheduled job still able to start to run at the scheduled time automatically? If not, am I able to start the job manually on the command line on the distributed machine without the FME Flow Core machine available?Your help is great appreciated. Thanks, -John

Is their a file size limit for loading data into the Resources folder?When the file reaches a certain size the file fails to load.Thanks Chris

Hey Team,We’re getting a really weird error on Flow/Server (2022.2), and unfortunately it seems to be one of those ones that we can’t really replicate!The Infrastructure setup is two hosts, with a mixture of standard engines and dynamic engines. We got the below errors across two (very) different workbenches, on the same engine/host (standard engine):  We had something similar a couple of weeks ago and resolved it by restarting the effected host. However, this time around it has seemed to fix itself (assuming it was restarted as part of the automatic engine recycling).Looking at the engine logs for that host, they don’t really give too much more info as to what has happenedTue-12-Mar-2024 10:37:00.923 AM INFORM Thread-13401 BANPRIFMESP01_Engine2 Translation Finished (service '7070'). Return message is '23001:Module 'SurfaceModelFactory' is unavailable for use with this FME edition|LogFileName=job_522412.log'Wondering if anyone has seen something similar or know what might be ca

I’m looking at upgrading our internal automated testing of our FME tools/workspace. At the moment the way I’m doing it is with custom docker images of FME Desktop/Form and running the tests inside these. This works OK, I’m able to automate the licensing and do what I need to do. But obviously with FME Form comes a lot of uneeded GUI stuff. Plus it just feels clunky and I always need to create a new docker file anytime a new version of FME comes out which I want to test against. (we build our tools in older versions of FME to try and support more customers on various FME versions) I know that there are docker-compose files for FME Flow which work well, however, I don’t really need the whole stack, just the Engine with which I can feed my tests. Also the way that I’m working makes using docker-compose difficult/annoying.In light of that does anyone know if there is a way to just use the FME Engine image on it’s own. This would really save my bacon and make may testing pipeline much more