Allow Attributes Based on Other Reader

Do you need dynamic schema configuration based on the attribute names list in the Excel file?

Hello Takashi,

Thank you for the reply.

Seems to be "Yes" to your question. I have not used dynamic schema until now.

Pratap

Hi,

I don't want to change the schema of writer because it has several other attributes and it is constant.

Pratap

The Schema (Any Format) reader can be used to read schema features from any dataset. A schema feature contains a structured list called "attribute{}", which stores attribute names ("attribute{}.name") and their data type names defined in a feature type of the source dataset.

My idea is:

1. Add a Schema (Any Format) reader to read schema feature from the source Shape file, and explode the feature on "attribute{}" using the ListExploder.
2. As well, add another Schema reader for the Excel file, and explode the schema feature.
3. Merge the exploded features from Excel to the exploded features from Shape using "name" (i.e. attribute name) as the join key.
4. Re-build "attribute{}" list from the Merged features using the ListBuilder or Aggregator. The re-built "attribute{}" list consists of only attributes coming from the Excel.
5. Merge the list to the output line features unconditionally.

You can then configure dynamic writer schema with the method described in this article: Destination Schema is Derived from List Attributes

If you don't want to change writer schema, just configure the schema statically?

I have made sample files and tried but unable to get the result as required as well as geometry as well.

Attached are the files with which I have tried. safe.zip

Could you please modify the workspace if I'm wrong

See this example: schema-schema2none.zip

Merge the excell schema with the writer schema?

If writer schema contains attributes from shape wich are to be discarded, you must alsoo remove those.

To do this you need to provide both writer schema (you said it is fixed, so this should be no problem) and the excell schema.

Use in a dynamic set-up.

I agree with Takashi, if your schema is static - i.e. the Excel file will never change you know that you only need attributes 2,4,6,7 - then edit the Writer schema to only include those attributes.

Alternatively, I can think of two other solutions for where it is not static (i.e. the Excel file might change):

1) Set the Writer schema to Automatic. Hide all the attributes on the Shape Reader, and connect both it and the Excel to the Writer. The schema will come from the Excel (and not from the Shape because its attributes are hidden) but the attribute values will come from the Shape (which are only hidden, not deleted). This works (I tried it) but it isn't truly dynamic - if the Excel changes you would need to update the Reader schema manually.

2) Set the Writer schema to Dynamic. Add the Excel as a Reader Resource. Set the source of the Writer schema to be the Excel dataset. Now only Shape attributes matching that dataset get written.

Although I too went down the exploded list route at first, I really don't think it is necessary. I'm quite pleased with how the first alternative works!

Here's a workspace template showing the first alternative method. The main problem I had is in data types (without data in the Excel FME defined them both as char(2) data types).

Thank you everyone for the responses.

@takashi, I have disabled the writer and checked the result with inspector but result is not matching as I required.

Seems like I have not posted clearly. I don't want to define writer schema or reader (i.e. point shape file as in this example) schema, those schema's are constant but contents of the excel file will change. As I told earlier, I'm controlling the attributes for translation with attribute keeper transformer. I want to replace this procedure with the help of excel file as it is easy for me. I receive excel file as one of the input i.e. Version 1.0 or Version 1.1. In this example I require ATTR_2,ATTR_5,ATTR_7,ATTR_9 attributes for translation but when I receive another version of excel I may require ATTR_3,ATTR_5,ATTR_6,ATTR_8

In this example the result should be point shape file with 16 points with ATTR_2,ATTR_5,ATTR_7,ATTR_9,ATTR_12,ATTR_13 attributes

i.e.ATTR_12 & ATTR_13 are additional attributes in writers and will be null

Pratap