+8Is there a way to control the size of labels within AutoCAD blocks during DWG rendering? The text looks smaller and is misaligned when rendered by FME (and therefore the inspector and, more importantly, the PNG writer), but it's the right size and aligned properly in AutoCAD.
Bad in FME (for Linux):
vs. Good in AutoCAD:
Best answer by kweller
Thanks @daveatsafe! I already use a Text Stroker feeding a MapnikRasterizer to produce my PNGs. The problem was more of a mis-alignment issue than a size issue. I just solved the problem by inserting an Offsetter to fix the former, and also by multiplying the font size by a factor of 1.4 to get the TextStroker and MapnikRasterizer to output something resembling what AutoCAD renders for the same content.
So I've solved the problem on my own. I just think It's odd that the default FME text positioning--not just the text size--is off.
+19Hi @kweller,
FME's default rasterization when writing to PNG is pretty basic when it comes to text. You can get better results if you use the TextStroker transformer before writing, which allows you to choose the font for the text to render.
For the best rasterization results, please look at the MapnikRasterizer, which allows you to fully control the appearance of your lines, polygons and text in the output raster. The setup can be a little complex, but the results are definitely worth it. For more information on the MapnikRasterizer capabilities, please see:
https://knowledge.safe.com/articles/1092/introduction-to-mapnikrasterizer.html
+8Thanks @daveatsafe! I already use a Text Stroker feeding a MapnikRasterizer to produce my PNGs. The problem was more of a mis-alignment issue than a size issue. I just solved the problem by inserting an Offsetter to fix the former, and also by multiplying the font size by a factor of 1.4 to get the TextStroker and MapnikRasterizer to output something resembling what AutoCAD renders for the same content.
So I've solved the problem on my own. I just think It's odd that the default FME text positioning--not just the text size--is off.
+19Thanks @daveatsafe! I already use a Text Stroker feeding a MapnikRasterizer to produce my PNGs. The problem was more of a mis-alignment issue than a size issue. I just solved the problem by inserting an Offsetter to fix the former, and also by multiplying the font size by a factor of 1.4 to get the TextStroker and MapnikRasterizer to output something resembling what AutoCAD renders for the same content.
So I've solved the problem on my own. I just think It's odd that the default FME text positioning--not just the text size--is off.
Hi @kweller,
There are a couple of AutoCAD quirks that may be responsible:
- AutoCAD stores the lower left location of the text, regardless of the justification set on the text, then recalculates the apparent placement point based on the font metrics. FME attempts to repeat the calculation to set the placement location as the attributes autocad_alignment_x, _y and _z. However, FME does not have access to the font metrics, and so this location is only approximate.
- AutoCAD's text size is based on the capital height of the font, while most other formats (and FME's rendering) use ascender plus descender. This results in the text shrinking to about .7 when converting to other formats. Unfortunately, DWG is one of FME's original 9 formats, and so we can't change this behavior without breaking 25 years of backwards compatibility.
+8Hi @kweller,
There are a couple of AutoCAD quirks that may be responsible:
- AutoCAD stores the lower left location of the text, regardless of the justification set on the text, then recalculates the apparent placement point based on the font metrics. FME attempts to repeat the calculation to set the placement location as the attributes autocad_alignment_x, _y and _z. However, FME does not have access to the font metrics, and so this location is only approximate.
- AutoCAD's text size is based on the capital height of the font, while most other formats (and FME's rendering) use ascender plus descender. This results in the text shrinking to about .7 when converting to other formats. Unfortunately, DWG is one of FME's original 9 formats, and so we can't change this behavior without breaking 25 years of backwards compatibility.
Yeah, I figured it was something like that. 25 years is a long time in terms of technology.
+23Thanks @daveatsafe! I already use a Text Stroker feeding a MapnikRasterizer to produce my PNGs. The problem was more of a mis-alignment issue than a size issue. I just solved the problem by inserting an Offsetter to fix the former, and also by multiplying the font size by a factor of 1.4 to get the TextStroker and MapnikRasterizer to output something resembling what AutoCAD renders for the same content.
So I've solved the problem on my own. I just think It's odd that the default FME text positioning--not just the text size--is off.
Hello @kweller, any chance you can share a snapshot of your solution (or the workbench :)) as I am trying to do a similar thing in trying to recreate the DWG output.
+8Hello @kweller, any chance you can share a snapshot of your solution (or the workbench :)) as I am trying to do a similar thing in trying to recreate the DWG output.
Sure! Here are a couple of screenshots. One is of the [Text]Offsetter and TextStroker that feed the MapnikRasterizer Text input port, and the other is the ExpressionEvaluator that updates the text font size (I went with 1.2x in the end).
+23Sure! Here are a couple of screenshots. One is of the [Text]Offsetter and TextStroker that feed the MapnikRasterizer Text input port, and the other is the ExpressionEvaluator that updates the text font size (I went with 1.2x in the end).
Thanks @kweller, what parameters did you us in the offsetter?
+8Thanks @kweller, what parameters did you us in the offsetter?
X +0.05 and Y -0.02. But that's dependent on the spatial reference system and the font I'm using, so your numbers will likely need to be different. I'd suggest you experiment until you get the image output you want.
Enter your E-mail address. We'll send you an e-mail with instructions to reset your password.
