It's slower on the machine that is supposed to be faster!
Solved
FME runs slower on one machine vs. another
+20- Safer
- 3719 replies
Best answer by fmelizard
Comparing program running times across different systems is hard to do.
If you see performance differences, here are some questions to ask.
- Are you using the same build?
- Are you using the same bit (32 vs 64)?
- Does each install of FME have the same access to the source/destination data?
- Are you using the same operating system?
- Are you using the same hardware?
- Is the source data located on SSD or HDD?
- Is one system running antivirus and the other is not?
- Is there contention for memory, disk, network, CPU, or other limiting resources?
- Are there other processes running?
You might interrogate the log files. Is there a slowdown across the whole processing or in one specific area? If it is in one specific area, then you might be able to identify the problem and resolve it. If it is across the whole processing time, then that might be harder to resolve.
In general, performance benchmarking is a hard problem. Many factors need to be static and those that cannot be controlled need to be minimized. Using different machines destroys most controls.
This post is closed to further activity.
It may be an old question, an answered question, an implemented idea, or a notification-only post.
Please check post dates before relying on any information in a question or answer.
For follow-up or related questions, please post a new question or idea.
If there is a genuine update to be made, please contact us and request that the post is reopened.
It may be an old question, an answered question, an implemented idea, or a notification-only post.
Please check post dates before relying on any information in a question or answer.
For follow-up or related questions, please post a new question or idea.
If there is a genuine update to be made, please contact us and request that the post is reopened.
+20- Safer
- 3719 replies
- Best Answer
Comparing program running times across different systems is hard to do.
If you see performance differences, here are some questions to ask.
- Are you using the same build?
- Are you using the same bit (32 vs 64)?
- Does each install of FME have the same access to the source/destination data?
- Are you using the same operating system?
- Are you using the same hardware?
- Is the source data located on SSD or HDD?
- Is one system running antivirus and the other is not?
- Is there contention for memory, disk, network, CPU, or other limiting resources?
- Are there other processes running?
You might interrogate the log files. Is there a slowdown across the whole processing or in one specific area? If it is in one specific area, then you might be able to identify the problem and resolve it. If it is across the whole processing time, then that might be harder to resolve.
In general, performance benchmarking is a hard problem. Many factors need to be static and those that cannot be controlled need to be minimized. Using different machines destroys most controls.
Trying to interpret FME performance issues is covered here
One area we often see a performance difference occur is when FME is deployed on a Virtual Machine and then runs slower than on a desktop. This is often due to a poorly configured VM environment where several VM machines are sharing resources that are actually designed for a single use machine - such as network bandwidth, memory resources, shared drives.
If you're accessing a database from the VM, then network latency on the VM cluster may be an issue. Again, the host VM machine must be capable of supporting the number of guest VM's machines, and this includes the network band with to support database access and network file system.
+18- Supporter
- 1442 replies
Trying to interpret FME performance issues is covered here
One area we often see a performance difference occur is when FME is deployed on a Virtual Machine and then runs slower than on a desktop. This is often due to a poorly configured VM environment where several VM machines are sharing resources that are actually designed for a single use machine - such as network bandwidth, memory resources, shared drives.
If you're accessing a database from the VM, then network latency on the VM cluster may be an issue. Again, the host VM machine must be capable of supporting the number of guest VM's machines, and this includes the network band with to support database access and network file system.
+20- Safer
- 3719 replies
Trying to interpret FME performance issues is covered here
One area we often see a performance difference occur is when FME is deployed on a Virtual Machine and then runs slower than on a desktop. This is often due to a poorly configured VM environment where several VM machines are sharing resources that are actually designed for a single use machine - such as network bandwidth, memory resources, shared drives.
If you're accessing a database from the VM, then network latency on the VM cluster may be an issue. Again, the host VM machine must be capable of supporting the number of guest VM's machines, and this includes the network band with to support database access and network file system.
If you are asking the question: why is one system performing better compared to another? - then it may not be useful to try interpret performance. Again, there is probably no value in trying to compare performance across different systems, because it is hard to do.
If you are asking the question: how can I improve the performance of one system? - then interpreting performance makes sense.
One of our users reported that disabling dynamic memory management used for the virtual machines environment improved memory allocation and performance.
+26- Supporter
- 321 replies
After working with @jlutherthomas today, I figured out that the major hardware constraint is your CPU speed. We have an FME Server setup with 9 cores clocked at 2.7Ghz. My desktop has 8 cores clocked at 3.6Ghz. A job I ran was 14 minutes faster on my desktop machine than it was on our FME server box with the same exact versions of FME tested and confirmed on the server box with both FME Desktop and FME Server.