Community Q+A

Hello,I try to do something very simple but I think I must be dumb. So I’m working with a ArcGIS Featureservices data which are agriculture data. In the RPG_2023, the attributes associated to “CODE_GROUP” will be only numbers like 11,16,18 so very simple.In the user parameter I try to add the “CHOICE” parameter because I want the script to ask me which kind of attribute I want to work with.I try to use the import wizard using the valuesBut then in this box is going endless ==>I don’t know if I do something wrong

Reading Living Atlas layers anonymously (no authentication) is done using the Standalone Server source type but the 3.21.2 package errors.  This is a publicly shared service you can try:https://services.arcgis.com/P3ePLMYs2RVChkJx/arcgis/rest/services/USA_Major_Cities_/FeatureServerSafe are aware of the issue, you can revert to 3.20.2 to avoid the issue.

Hi,Does anyone else have any trouble accessing Safe webinars these days? They are usually in the middle of the night for me, so I used to watch any relevant ones after a video becomes available. They a good professional development hours.I always used to be able to watch them on demand. However, I haven’t seen a video in 6 months. I seem to be only have the option of attending live. Does anyone know what’s going on? Does Safe not provide on demand videos anymore?I did send a support request a few weeks ago but I have not had a response.Thanks  

HI anyone else else getting a 403 error (ERROR: No permission for specified URL) with the TGIF link.https://community.safe.com/thank-goodness-it-s-fme-91/introducing-tgif-thank-goodness-it-s-fme-40120https://community.safe.com/thank-goodness-it-s-fme-91Yes I am logged in?Cheers,

I have a very simple workflow setup:read a table (typically either a .CSV or Excel file) which then connects to an Attribute Manager set up with multiple fields from a template that adds and renames them so they can be seamlessly imported into another database with exactly the same field names; and then this connects to  Excel Writer (the file format required for import)Since the files I’m reading into FME Workbench do not have all the fields or match exactly those in the template/Attribute Manager has (the point of the workflow), I get an “incomplete transformer” error message. The workflow executes flawlessly, however, and I’m getting the results I need.I’m wondering, however, if there is a way to eliminate the error - the red “incomplete transformer” icon in the navigator window is a bit disconcerting. 😉 PS: I have added the following annotation to the AttributeManager should there be no way to get rid of the error m

Hello Team,I have an Excel template with a single worksheet that includes predefined colours, formatting, etc.In version 2025.0, I’m trying to write my results into this template, but I want to output multiple worksheets within the same workbook using the same template. I’ve tried several approaches (both dynamic and manual), but they either fail or behave unexpectedly.What I’m seeing is that only the first worksheet shows the designed template but no results, while the subsequent worksheets contain the results but lose the template formatting. Even when I set Remove Template Sheet if Unchanged to Yes, the first worksheet (the template sheet) is still present with no results filled in.Does anyone know whether this is achievable in version 2025.0? If so, how should it be configured in the Excel Writer?Kind regardsThanks!

Moving this to FME Form Q/A.  

Hello everyone,I am seeking confirmation on whether GeometryValidator supports 3D geometry validation (such as solids, meshes, point clouds, etc.) in version 2025.0I noticed that GeometryValidator includes an issue type called “Self-Intersection in 2D”, which suggests that this one specifically built for 2D geometry. However, I would like to understand whether the other issue types - such as Missing Vertex Normals, Missing Texture Coordinates, Invalid Solid Boundaries, Invalid Solid Voids, Contains Non-Planar Surfaces, Invalid Area Orientation, Surface Orientation, and others - are applicable to and capable of validating 3D data.Could you please clarify which of these validations support 3D geometries?Thanks in advanced!

We recently upgraded our FME Flow from version 2019 to FME 2025.2.1. Although we encountered several issues during the upgrade, the system is now running. However, we are facing a new error when executing an existing workbench. The workbench reads data from an Oracle table and generates GML and GeoJSON files. The files are generated successfully, but at the end of the process, the following error appears: 190 2026-1-20 14:33:00 | Router and Unexpected Input Remover (RoutingFactory): No geometry mapping entry found for 'fme_line' in metafile 'E:\Server\fme\metafile\ORACLE_SPATIAL.fmf'. Please visit http://www.safe.com/support Has anyone encountered this issue before? Any guidance would be appreciated.  

hi All, i am currently using FME2015, May i check if we are able to use openJDK to replace JRE so that we do not need to use Java Oracle license? Thank you.

I have an excel file that has changing header position at every ingestion. The header is randomly stated into any row position and before the header data is populated until row 4 (not always stable). I have been using these configuration where the Field Names Row is set to 1 and Cell Range is blank by default. However when the different file is ingested, these values automatically changes to 1 and 2:as attached in the screenshot.  I tried changing the attribute definition to manual, however it terminates the translation when the feature type changes. What is the best approach to this issue given that the names in the header remains always stable?

Hi, What is the best way to manage the schema drifting issue? Context: Currently the user uploads an Excel File through Workspace apps, and the file contains multiple attributes where the attribute names can change anytime. ID can be reported as Id, Identifier, id, ID. What is the best way to map and standardize these attributes ?

I wanted to make all my attribute to camelCase, currently they are separated by underscore.I wanted to change my attribute name to camelCase, so using regular expression in BulkAttributeRenamer transformer to find text following underscore using regular expression replace: _([a-z])  However, i am not sure what String parameter i have to put to make the selected character Capital letter. I have tried \U\1 and also few other but its not working. Basically wanting to find String parameter value? 

I’m using the Gemini Connector (Transformer) in FME and facing an issue with initiator (upstream) attributes.My requirement is:The attributes coming into the Gemini Connector (initiator attributes) Need to be merged with the Gemini response/output, so that the final feature contains both the original attributes and the Gemini result Current behavior: The Gemini Connector output only contains response-related attributes Initiator attributes are not carried through or merged automatically Question: Is there a supported way to merge or carry initiator attributes along with the Gemini response? Is this a limitation of the Gemini Connector transformer? What is the recommended pattern (FeatureMerger, Joiner, correlation ID, etc.) to achieve this? Any guidance, b

Hi,I have text from a source DWG that contains all the information needed to create an annotation class in a geodatabase (text size, rotation, color hex/RGB/fme, etc.). I’m able to create the annotation class in the GDB, but all the text comes in as black, even though the original text has different colors.What am I missing?

Hi,Is anyone else having issues with Form not starting after the recent Windows update? A repair did not help, and even a fresh installation of version 2025.2.3 will not start.

lets say I have a set of coordinates x1,y1 and x2,y2 how can i create a dwg with dimensions between these coordinates?if possible a step by step guide with the transformers/writers required for this.  

Working in FME Workbench v.2024.2I am working on a process that validates my metadata format and converts it if needed, then exports the final format to xml for backup. We are trying to ensure all of our metadata is in ISO 19139, but we know some feature classes are FGDC CSDGM Metadata. We would like to use FME to convert the format and then update/write to the existing feature class's metadata in our enterprise geodatabase with it. Secondly, we want to also create a backup of the xml file which will be saved to a local folder. I have done this using an "Attribute File Writer" and only writing the geodb_metadata_string to a .xml file, however, when trying to reimport it into ArcMap/ArcGIS Pro I receive a "Failed to import metadata" alert. Comparing it an export directly from ArcGIS it is clear they differ. It seems like FME is converting it to their own format when reading it in.Any suggestions on either of these processes would be appreciated, thanks!

Hello all,I would like to automatically record different Output Port names ​​into one new attribute. So in the newly generated output file there is al column with the name of the Output Port and a column with the value from the TestFilter.Desired outcomeI know it is possible to do it by hand, place a AttributeCreater behind every port and fill in the Output Port name. But I have a large number of TestFilters, and to avoid errors and keep things organized, I would like to do it automatically with one AttributeCreator/AttributeManager.If the AttributeCreator/AttributeManager is not the correct transformer, or I need two other transformers that do the job, that would already make a big difference to me.  

Greetings everyone,I have a large number of 2D polygons for which I want to determine the Z value. I also have a DTM (digital terrain model).Now I have observed the following: If I take only one polygon and, using the FeatureReader, read in only exactly those triangles of the DTM that are touched by the polygon in 2D, and then determine the Z values of the polygon using the SurfaceDraper (always carrying forward only z_max and using that as the Z value via the 3D_Forcer), I get different Z values than when I first create a buffer around the polygon and then pass the buffer to the FeatureReader and include the triangles around the polygon in the SurfaceDraper.The triangles from the DTM do not touch each other.There are deviations of several meters, depending on how strongly the terrain height varies around the polygon.It seems as if the SurfaceDraper somehow takes the surrounding terrain into account, even if it does not touch the polygon.It

Is there any chance of getting a search bar added to the forums?  The forums are very useful, but would be even better if we could search on previously written topics

N/A

I try to find a text ending with a newline. Using the inbuilt regular expression editor (with the regex #! <DATASET\n) shows a result so the regex looks correct to me:StringSearcher unfortunately doesn’t find the line: (see attached workbench)Where are things going wrong?

We require support to establish a structured version management and governance process for FME workspaces (.fmw files) using Azure DevOps (ADO).Currently, FME files are updated manually, which creates challenges around version control, traceability, rollback, and collaborative development. We would like guidance and support on leveraging ADO repositories and pipelines to manage FME files effectively.The objective is to: Maintain version history of FME workspaces Enable controlled check-in/check-out and collaboration Support rollback and auditability Align with enterprise DevOps and SDLC standards Please advise on best practices, recommended repository structure, branching strategy, and CI/CD considerations (if applicable) for managing FME files in ADO.

Hi,I have a very simple workbench that is cliping a gpkg containing mulitple layer. I am struggling with writinng them back to one gpkg using dynamic schema. it fails every single time