How to add multiple different buffer for multiple point?

Hi @juhaszvanda,

There is also a custom transformer - the MultiBufferer that will allow you to do this in a single transformer. It only uses a single buffer interval so will only be useful if desired outcome buffers are equal distances apart.

You can find the transformer documentation here: https://hub.safe.com/transformers/multibufferer

buffers-for-points-test-with-kfigur.fmwtestrv.csv

kfigur,

Thank you for your suggestion. I created the same WP as you and ended up with the same result. I attached the CSV this time. Could you take a look please.

Thank you, Vanda

Hi @juhaszvanda

 

 

Unfortunately your workspace is still unavailable :

 

However from the instructions above my guess would be that your points do not have a Coordinate System. The bufferer uses the Coordinate System to determine which unit it will add the buffer in, e.g. metres, feet, degrees, so if that is unknown then the buffers will not appear as you would expect. You can use the CoordinateSystemSetter after the Vertex Creator to get this set up.

 

Using the test data you provided this gives me the following result:

 

Dear @hollyatsafe

Thank you very much for looking into my issues. I did what you suggested and ended up with the wrong result again. So, here are some question where I think I might making a mistake.

When I bring in the CSV file, I set the Parameters - chose Manual and set Lat and Long as Y coordinate and X coordinate and not a string. Is this necessary or not?

Next, where the data originates its stored in GCS_North_American_1927. This is what I need to set in the CSV file when I added as a Reader?

If I set the coordinate system in the Reader why do we need the CoordinateSystemSetter? I thought FME can read the source data CRS and use the same throughout the who calculation.

I attached a Word document with screenshots and I used my Grant program licence to re-creach the WS, hopefully this time will work.

Thanks again for the help. @juhaszvandascreenshots-for-holly.ziptest-with-holly.fmw

Hi @juhaszvanda

 

 

No problem. Yes you have set up the VertexCreator correctly and if you set the Coordinate System in the CSV reader then it is not necessary to also use a CoordinateSystemSetter. The problem is that NAD27-48.LL is recorded in degrees:

 

So the buffer is taking the measures from the ROE attributes and trying to express them as degrees - with some impossible values literally out of this world. What unit are these measurements recorded in?

 

You have two options to get the desired result:

 

a) Reproject the data to a new coordinate system after the VertexCreator using a Reprojector - this will plot the points in a coordinate that carries the correct unit for the unit needed in the Bufferer.

 

b) Instead of the Bufferer use the GeographicBufferer. This does the same thing as the bufferer but allows you to set a Buffer Distance Unit different to that of the CoordinateSystem.

 

 

If you want to use a lat/long projection then option B is the best way to go for you. You can get more information about the GeographicBufferer and where it differs from the Bufferer here: https://docs.safe.com/fme/html/FME_Desktop_Documentation/FME_Transformers/Transformers/geographicbufferer.htm

 

 

Please find attached an altered workspace with the two options (this assumes the measurement unit is meters) .

 

test-with-hollyv2.fmwt