Hi @todd_davis

 

 

Thanks so much for taking the time to play with automations and give your feedback!

 

 

The repeat configuration steps, especially for email, has been brought up already internally. I believe it would be significant development effort to allow that to happen. I'm imaging that it would be like an expansion of the current web/database connections functionality that we have in desktop. Even being able to save defaults as you can with transformers would be useful.

One option you could do for the multiple configurations issue would be to create a automations/notifications hybrid. So if you want to use the same email publication/action several times or need to update it, you could create the rest of the automation and then create an email publication and use the automation to trigger that publication. Whilst not the tidiest approach, whilst we're at the early stages and first release of automations I think this would give you what you're after. You'd also then only need to update it in one place, if something like the password or template needed to change. And as the notification service isn't going away, for experienced users in some cases that may be the best solution. I think the hope here is automations will enable more one-off workflows to be created and help new users leverage this capability.

If you do post all of these ideas, it might be nice to also link them here so anyone who comes across this post can contribute in a specific location to that idea.

 

 

I'll definitely pass this post on to our Server Development team, and if anything else comes out that will help with this I'll let you know.

 

And definitely keep playing with automations and let us know what you think!

---

Thanks @jlutherthomas

Like you mention, I will probably rely on the topic notification via the automations in the meantime for us (not sure I can force that on clients though). I am going to see how I can report on the automations in an understandable format, so might have some comments, once I have really had a play with the api side.

 

 

 

---

Also, if you don't fill out details within the automation, there is no warning that you have left things empty.

Another idea lodged:

https://knowledge.safe.com/idea/87723/fme-server-automations-warn-when-processes-incompl.html

---

I totally agree.

My take after having played around just a little bit: it would be really useful if there was some global key/value storage for the automations, which you could reference wherever in the configuration. Something just like workspace published parameters, in fact.

That would allow you to change e.g. user names, URLs or mail servers in a single place, directly affecting all existing automations.

---

I totally agree.

My take after having played around just a little bit: it would be really useful if there was some global key/value storage for the automations, which you could reference wherever in the configuration. Something just like workspace published parameters, in fact.

That would allow you to change e.g. user names, URLs or mail servers in a single place, directly affecting all existing automations.

So there are global key value pairs that you can assign, but they can only be used within the same automation, not across multiple unfortunately. The doc on that is here.

---

So there are global key value pairs that you can assign, but they can only be used within the same automation, not across multiple unfortunately. The doc on that is here.

Thanks, yes I've seen those. But it would be very useful to have some key/value pairs that you could use across multiple automations as well.

---

Thanks, yes I've seen those. But it would be very useful to have some key/value pairs that you could use across multiple automations as well.

Hi @david_r. Thank you for the idea. I can definitely see this being quite useful as well. Would you mind posting this as a new idea? And it would be great if you could elaborate a bit more on your usage scenario and needs, especially in the context of multiple users, and the management of these key/value pairs.

 

Thank you very much!

---